The NY Times has an article here about the Uncommon Charter
Schools, a string of around thirty schools in the Northeast. The interesting aspect is that they are very
successful in raising math scores, but not reading scores. From the article:
“Is it a vocabulary issue? A background knowledge issue? A
sentence length issue? How dense is the text?” Mr. Peiser said, rattling off a
string of potential reading roadblocks. “It’s a three-dimensional problem that
you have to attack. And it just takes time.”
How absurd. The
problem is that no one is taking the time to turn these kids into avid
readers. Another quote:
“During a fifth-grade reading
class, students read aloud from “Bridge to Terabithia,” by Katherine Paterson.
Naomi Frame, the teacher, guided the students in a close reading of a few
paragraphs. But when she asked them to select which of two descriptions fit
Terabithia, the magic kingdom created by the two main characters, the class
stumbled to draw inferences from the text.”
Professor Stephen Krashen, in his book The Power
of Reading, cites research showing the teaching skills is just testing
skills; kids acquire skills through wide
reading. It’s hard to image a way more
guaranteed to turn kids off to books than making them do the kind of exercises
described above.
One despairs.
Well said! Reading lessons that mimic reading testing will not improve kids reading; that's like trying to make kids grow taller by measuring their height a lot but never feeding them.
ReplyDelete